Head of a young man costumed as a stereotypica...

Image via Wikipedia

I want to call your attention to this article from one of my favorite sites, Lifehacker called Get Better Deals Online by Breaking the Seller’s Confidence. While not a scam in the truest sense of the word, this money saving advice does involve playing a physiological trick on the seller and is a bit, well, shady.

To quote the article,

If you see something you like on Kijiji, Craigslist, or whatever equivalent, try using two (or more, if you have the patience) email accounts to make the poster think their item is worth less. Make a really low-ball with the first account, and if they decline shrug it off and respond saying it isn’t worth it. Then, offer a better but still low-ball price with the second account.

So there’s nothing illegal going on, just a little mind game where you make the seller think there is a demand for the item at a lower price when that demand is really just you on another account. If a person had more then one account on a site like eBay or Bonanza, they could do this same thing just as easily.

Is it moral? Would you, as a seller, fall for this?

You can read the article in full here.

7 Comments

  1. Cliff Aliperti

    Nah, my price is my price, so if I’m falling for it it’s only because the second offer met what I needed.  Shoot, I hope some ambitious buyers give this a go, it can only mean more sales in the end!

    Reply
    • Hillary

      I think, especially for people like you and I who sell the same stuff all the time and know what it’s worth, it wouldn’t work. But I’m thinking about those times when I get something random that I have no concept of and my BIN price is a totally shot in the dark anyway. I’d probably go for it. 

      But if that’s what I’m willing to sell it for, is that really a scam? Didn’t I just sell it for what I felt like selling it for?

      Reply
  2. Tula

    I’ve seen an increase in disdain and a general lack of respect for those who sell, especially businesses. Not a day goes by where I don’t see blog comments demonizing businesses or suggesting ways to “screw” them in some way. Like the fact that they’re a business makes them inherently evil somehow or making it less of a crime to steal from them. It’s kind of sad.

    Reply
  3. Fine Estate Sales

    …OH Joy…Yet More Ways To Torment The Unaware…As If Anyone Needs To Be Taught Yet More Ways…

    Reply
  4. AngelaTC

    My first comment here: Awkward!!! I kind of did this once.  Back in the early days of eBay, I was out scouring garage sales and came across a woman who had several sets of Fisher Price Little People toys lined up in her driveway.  I knew what they would sell for, so I offered her about half of that. She said no, politely explaining that she knew what they were worth,  so I left my number and invited her to call me if they were still available at the end of the sale.

    I went home and told my husband that I was bummed about missing the buy, because there was an easy $100 sale there. He asked where the house was, drove over there and offered her $10 less, thinking that perhaps would motivate her into calling me as the day began to wind down.  Instead, she sold them to him!

    Reply
    • Hillary

      haha, that’s classic, Angela!

      Reply
  5. Dave Lucas

    It’s absolutely moral! Most sellers overprice items anyway!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

About The Whine Seller

With over two decades of experience selling online, The Whine Seller is about sharing the ins and outs of e-commerce, publishing and more… in a snarky way. Keep reading…

Sell Their Stuff
from eBay Trading Assistants to multi-channel seller assistance, your ultimate guide to consignment selling online as a part-time income or full-time business

eBay Marketing Makeover
Increase sales and grow traffic to your eBay items by encouraging word of mouth, focusing on your ideal buyers, and optimizing your selling for search and mobile


Beyond Amazon, eBay, and Etsy
free and low cost alternative marketplaces, shopping cart solutions and e-commerce storefronts

The Seller Ledger
An Auction Organizer for Selling on eBay

Affiliate disclaimer

I may earn a small commission on links to any products or services from the following websites.