The Whine Seller

10 Jan, 2009

Editorial: But eBay! I don’t want to sign up for ProPay, Moneybookers OR Paymate!

Posted by: Hillary In: Editorials and Opinion Pieces| Ranting and Whining| Sound off| eBay

(I planned to reopen The Whine Seller next week with a more positive note but eBay went and ticked me off so, sorry, two bitter rants in two days!).

eBay added two more approved Payment Methods to its approved list yesterday, Mooneybookers and Paymate now join eBay owned PayPal and newcomer ProPay. As part of the same announcement, ProPay will be opening up to all PowerSellers (they had previously only been open to certain levels).

While the big debate yesterday in various eBay related blogs was the trustworthiness of these two new options, I have to admit that I don’t really care what the details of these new services are. All I care about is that eBay just added some new payment methods and now I feel forced into offering them.

I rejoiced when they banned money orders. Why? Because money orders were more work (wait for them to arrive, check the mail every day, take them to the bank, wait for them to clear, too easy to fake) and only a tiny percentage of my buyers used them. Then why did I offer them? Because in an auction driven business, to me, every payment method you don’t offer is another bidder that you are alienating who may not bid on your stuff. If eBay makes it an option, you basically have to offer it or you risk losing bidders and buyers.

So by adding these three new services, they are basically forcing me to sign up for them. Might these new services be better than PayPal? Sure, it’s always an option. Might they even be cheaper? It’s possible, I haven’t even looked. But it doesn’t matter if they are all worse and more expensive. I will have to sign up for them anyway and that is what annoys me.

I know some people hated what they saw as the monopoly of eBay requiring only PayPal (which they owned) but, to me, the marketplace needed to be standardized. Throwing 3 new services with three new policies, processes and confusions into the mix isn’t going to help but only hurt in the long run.

I know, I sound like the oldest woman ever. I swear to god, I’m not. See? But everytime they add a new approved payment method, no matter what it is, it annoys me.

Maybe one of you can sell me on why adding new payment methods is a good thing because I am just not feeling it.

Share this page with others:

  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • TwitThis
  • Google
  • Facebook
  • MySpace
  • LinkedIn
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • Slashdot

Related posts



5 Responses to "Editorial: But eBay! I don’t want to sign up for ProPay, Moneybookers OR Paymate!"

1 | KIMI

January 10th, 2009 at 8:30 am

Avatar

as i know, moneybookers does not chargeback, mean if u pay with your credit card through MB, u can’t chargeback..

sorry for my poor english

KIMI’s last blog post..Red Sonja- Rectangular Italian Charm Watches.-RICW02

2 | Henrietta

January 10th, 2009 at 11:00 am

Avatar

So far as Moneybookers is concerned, you can’t sign up. See the update on my Three Beards post yesterday for more rant material. Too funny.

Henrietta’s last blog post..The Three Beards

3 | Marvin

January 11th, 2009 at 11:56 am

Avatar

Just a comment about you rejoicing about the ban on money orders and other paper payments ( I have rants too :).) Like many other things, too many people want to force THEIR limitations on others, and this seems to be one of those instances. It appears you using this ban as an excuse for you so you don’t have to offer paper payments rather than just not offer them in the first place. I don’t work for oBay, and their tome of site restrictions/requirements are more of a political statement designed to CYA than encouraging the community that was once known as eBay. Rant off :).

BTW, I loved it when Amazon disallowed Bill Me Later from their approved payment methods when oBay bought it!

4 | Hillary

January 11th, 2009 at 12:21 pm

Avatar

Hey, cool! My little show the commentator’s last blog post plugin is finally working! Woohoo! (It’s the little things, people!)

I actually have a whole separate rant on money orders but I am trying to be less rant-y (like a shanty but more angry) so I am saving that for a later date so its not three rants in a row. :-)

I know some of you are saying that, in the end, it’s optional to offer money orders or not or to sign up for these services but, to me, it isn’t. With auctions, 1 extra bidder can make a huge difference in price and unless I offer every payment method allowed, I am taking the risk of turning away buyers.

Henrietta, I read your post and pretty much was like, eh, I’ll put off looking at those sites until I have to. So far, there hasn’t been any news to make me want to run out and sign up for any of them.

5 | Why I Love eBay | Kidpedia - sponsored by Goodnite Moon

January 12th, 2009 at 10:46 am

Avatar

[...] Hillary DePiano of The Whine Seller: Editorial: But eBay! I don’t want to sign up … [...]

Comment Form

Project Wonderful - Your ad here, right now, for as low as $0.00


  • permacrisis: Anyone who begins their first sentence with "So," is either self-important, patronizing, or about to launch into Bayspeak. Anybody else catch that?
  • Angelize: I never understood that kind of "selling" either. I especially stay away from those that have only two lines of description and a three-foot long TOS
  • Angelize: I wholeheartedly agree with you! I've been on eBay (buying AND selling) since 1999 but I've only been on eBay's message boards for the past six month

About

Author Hillary DePiano shares her decade of internet experience, helping buyers and sellers both to make the most out of e-commerce and online shopping with tips, advice, articles and editorials about eBay, Amazon, Lulu, Cafepress, and more. With only minor whining and complaining.

Subscribe to The Whine Seller by Email

Top Three Commenters