When I was in college, I was selling a huge batch of Star Trek figures for a Trading Assistant client before Christmas. One of my good friends was a casual eBay buyer but was fascinated by the selling aspect of it and used to watch my auctions all the time. (Interesting fact: Said friend was the roommate for 4 years of my now husband.)

He imed me and asked if he could bid on some of my items. I told him, of course, and he ended up winning one of the figures (I sadly don’t remember which one). Mind you, it took him like 3 weeks to pay me which is even more pathetic since I saw him every day, especially since when he did finally pay it was via PayPal which I consider to be a party foul since he made me pay fees. I naturally ribbed him about this.

After shouting across the quad at him, “Don’t make me file a non-paying bidder report on you! Don’t think I won’t do it!” he finally paid me that day and I walked over to his dorm and handed him his item (fastest and easiest shipping ever).

So the next day I am looking at my feedback and my buddy had left me feedback and it was a positive and all it said was, “Enjoy the eggnog!” I’m like, what kind of feedback is that? Then, on a whim, I walk over to the fridge in my apartment and there is a carton of eggnog with a post-it note on it that says “for Hillary.” I consider this a more than fair trade for making me wait and pay PayPal fees.

Sadly, that feedback is so buried back in my feedback list I couldn’t even find it to get the exact wording or date but it will stick forever in my mind as my favorite feedback ever.

So consider this a little wish from me that you and yours have an excellent holiday, whichever holiday you celebrate, and a wonderful, and successful, New Year!

1 Comment

  1. Cliff Aliperti

    Hey, 3 weeks to pay back in the day wasn’t all that unusual …neither was 3 weeks to ship though say I’d say you more than held up your seller end of the bargain! In fact back then it wouldn’t have been entirely crazy to drink the egg nog and pack off the Star Trek figure to him in the empty carton.

    Merry Christmas, Hillary!

    Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Tweets that mention Happy Holidays: my favorite eBay feedback comment » The Whine Seller: e-commerce, eBay, selling online, self-publishing, marketing, social networking and more -- Topsy.com - [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Hillary DePiano. Hillary DePiano said: My favorite eBay feedback of all time…

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

About The Whine Seller

With over two decades of experience selling online, The Whine Seller is about sharing the ins and outs of e-commerce, publishing and more… in a snarky way. Keep reading…

Sell Their Stuff
from eBay Trading Assistants to multi-channel seller assistance, your ultimate guide to consignment selling online as a part-time income or full-time business

eBay Marketing Makeover
Increase sales and grow traffic to your eBay items by encouraging word of mouth, focusing on your ideal buyers, and optimizing your selling for search and mobile


Beyond Amazon, eBay, and Etsy
free and low cost alternative marketplaces, shopping cart solutions and e-commerce storefronts

The Seller Ledger
An Auction Organizer for Selling on eBay

Affiliate disclaimer

I may earn a small commission on links to any products or services from the following websites.